Category Archives: Returning

Information on Habitual Residence Condition

There is some valuable information for immigrants who are returning to Ireland in the Crosscare Migrant Project newsletter this month. It is below for your information. Please advise returning immigrants accordingly and advise them to seek assistance from Crosscare if their application is denied:

Crosscare Migrant Project has had a number of returning Irish clients who at initial presentation to their local social welfare office or community welfare officer were verbally told that there was no point in applying as they would not satisfy the Habitual Residence Condition (HRC).

In a number of cases this has resulted in the person not making an application based on the misinformation that they would not be entitled to a payment.  Such instances have involved only cursory enquiries into the person’s circumstances by the officer.

A person has a right to make a written application and should insist on making one if they feel they are entitled to a payment so that the full circumstances of their case can be properly examined.  Applicants also have the right to written reasons for refusals.

Verbal interactions that do not involve written applications or explanations are generally not recorded and do not show up on the already considerable statistics of Irish people who are refused a payment based on the HRC.

People should also be informed of their right to apply for a Supplementary Welfare Allowance payment while awaiting the outcome of their social welfare claim.

If you would like more information on the Habitual Residence Condition and how it may affect a returning Irish citizen, or if you are aware of any cases of Irish people refused a payment based on failure to satisfy the HRC, please get in touch with us.

See the whole newsletter at http://migrantproject.ie/documents/ReturningtoIrelande-bulletin-No.3September2010_000.pdf

Guide for immigrants returning to Ireland with non-Irish spouses

Irish immigrants who may be thinking of returning to Ireland with a non-Irish spouse should be aware that there is no automatic entitlement under Irish law for an Irish citizen to have their non-European Economic Area spouse, partner or other family member to join them in Ireland. Dublin’s Crosscare Migrant Project provides detailed information on the steps you need to take to apply for residency on their website: Residency Information for Family Members & Partners of Irish Citizens

Habitual residency condition resulting in benefits denial to returning immgrants

The CIIC has long been concerned that the current social welfare rules regarding residency are resulting in denial of social welfare benefits to immigrants who return from the United States.
Applicants who have lived in the US for the previous two years or more will have to show documentary evidence that Ireland is now their “center of interest.” It is important to be aware that there is a presumption that the applicant is not habitually resident in Ireland at the time of making the application until the contrary is shown by him or her. The onus is on the applicant to prove that s/he is habitually resident in the State.

Recent reports indicate that this, Habitual Residency Requirement or HRC is indeed resulting in the denial of benefits to returning Irish immigrants. The Irish Times. and the Examiner recently reported that the number of Irish citizens who were refused payments because they failed to satisfy residency requirements increased by almost 75% last year.

This is a major concern to Irish Centers here because their clients who are undocumented here do not have the option of returning to the US if they have no means of support at home. While the increase in the refusal rate in 2009 may be the result of the Government’s attempt to crack down on welfare fraud it is unconscionable to deny basic benefits to returning citizens.

If you are an Irish citizen who is intending to return home after living here for 2 years or more be sure to check out our blog to get the facts before you leave. Contact your local Irish Center for more information.

Extended family ruling may affect returning emigrants

The Irish high court recently ruled on an issue that might be of interest to some people who are thinking of returning to Ireland with extended family who may not be Irish. The ruling refused permission to an Irish man, his Chinese-born wife and their two Irish-born children to bring a High Court challenge to the State’s refusal to allow her widowed mother to live with them in Ireland. Read more in this Irish Times report.

Habitual residency: the facts

The Habitual Residency Condition is an issue that is of concern to many returning emigrants – the CIIC has put together this factsheet to inform you about what the requirements are, and where you can go for further assistance.

The Habitual Residency Condition
What is the habitual residency condition?
The habitual residency condition (HRC) requires that any applicant for a social welfare payment in Ireland, regardless of nationality, must show that they arehabitually resident in Ireland or the Common Travel Area. Applicants who have not lived in Ireland or any part of the Common Travel Area for the previous two years or more will have to show documentary evidence that Ireland is now their “centre of interest.”

It is important to be aware that there is a presumption that the applicant is not habitually resident in the State at the time of making the application until the contrary is shown by him or her. The onus is on the applicant to prove that s/he is habitually resident in the State.

Who is likely to be affected?

This is an important issue for Irish residents who are returning home because, to be eligible to receive Social Assistance payments in Ireland, returned immigrants must meet the HRC requirement by proving that their main center of interest is now in Ireland. 

Generally an applicant who has been present in Ireland for the preceding 2 years or more, works here and has a settled intention to remain in Ireland and make it his/her permanent home will satisfy the habitual residence condition. Returning immigrants will need to be prepared to document that it is their intention to remain in Ireland permanently, that they have no further interest in the US that they do not have a home or a job there.

Important Note: An applicant who satisfies the habitual residence condition must also satisfy the other conditions of entitlement in order to receive the payment claimed. Satisfying the habitual residency condition does not in and of itself qualify an applicant for a payment.

What payments are subject to the habitual residency condition?
Since May 2004 the following payments are now subject to a habitual residency condition:

  • Unemployment Assistance
  • Old Age Non-Contributory Pension
  • Blind Pension
  • Widow(er)’s and Orphan’s Non-Contributory Pensions
  • One-parent Family Payment
  • Carer’s Allowance
  • Disability Allowance
  • Supplementary Welfare Allowance (other than once-off exceptional and urgent needs payments) and
  • Child Benefit

How to prove Ireland is your centre of interest
The United States is not part of the Common Travel area so meeting the Habitual Residency Requirement is somewhat of a hurdle for some immigrants who are returning from the U.S. Some documents that would help to show that Ireland is now their center of interest include:

  • Showing that they have a home in Ireland, a lease or a mortgage in their name, a letter from family stating that they are living with them
  • A letter from an employer or documentation showing what they have been doing to try to get work
  • Letters and written statements from friends, family, priests, community leaders and organizations that show close community ties in Ireland
  • Get a PPS number if you do not have one
  • Join clubs or organizations and show proof of this

How to prove you’ve cut your ties with the US
Documentation that immigrants can use to show that they have cut their ties with the US includes:

  • Document that they have terminated their tenancy or sold their house in the US.
  • Letter of resignation or a letter, on letterhead, from a US employer stating that employment has ended.
  • Deportation paperwork
  • Proof that they purchased a one way ticket
  • Proof of a closed bank account and/or other key accounts in their name (electric, gas, telephone)
  • Letters from their children’s schools indicating that they have withdrawn them.
  • Letters from doctors, dentists etc. showing that they have terminated with them and/or requested records.
  • Letter from an Irish Center outlining their circumstances and their stated intent to return to Ireland permanently.

Keep your documents together
Immigrants who have been living in the USA for a number of years and who will be applying for Social Assistance payments, including Child Benefit, when they move home to Ireland are advised to gather and bring the appropriate documents with them as it can be difficult to gather them once they have left the United States. Mail the packet in advance to a trusted friend or relative who will keep it safe until the immigrant gets home. This may be more important for some clients who are less organized, or suffer from mental health issues, but is probably a good idea for everyone because paperwork can easily be misplaced in chaos of moving.
Include a letter on a US Irish Center’s letterhead that outlines the client’s circumstances and confirms that Ireland is their stated center of interest with contact information for the Center.

What if you are denied benefits?
Decisions can be appealed to the independent Social Welfare Appeals Office or in the case of Supplementary Welfare Allowance to a Health Board Appeals Officer and if necessary to the independent Social Welfare Appeals Office.

Further information
For further information before you leave the US contact your local Irish Center. To find the Center in your area check the Coalition of Irish Immigration Centers website.

Contact the Department of Social and Family Affairs, Information Services in Ireland at 01-7043000, by sending an e-mail to info@welfare.ie and on theirwebsite

Contact Crosscare Migrant Project in Dublin to seek assistance if benefits are denied to get assistance with filing an appeal. Senior citizens, on limited incomes who want to return to Ireland can seek help to access affordable housing and get information on the HRC requirement from The Safe Home Programme.